Class of 1976
- Raymond Clapp, Contributor
- Fendley Collins, Coach
- Tommy Evans, Wrestler/Coach
- Edward Gallagher, Coach
- Art Griffith, Coach
- Danny Hodge, Wrestler
- Clifford Keen, Coach
- Dave McCuskey, Coach
- George Mehnert, Wrestler
- Hugo Otopalik, Coach
- Rex Peery, Wrestler/Coach/Contributor
- Myron Roderick, Wrestler/Coach
- Billy Sheridan, Coach
- Jack VanBetter, Wrestler
Class of 1977
- Jess Hoke, Contributor
- Paul Keen, Coach
- William Koll, Wrestler/Coach
- Gerald Leeman, Wrestler/Coach
- Charlie Mayser, Contributor
- Terrence McCann, Wrestler/Contributor
- Earl McCready, Wrestler
- Port Robertson, Coach
- Russell Vis, Wrestler
- Henry Wittenberg, Wrestler
Class of 1978
- Glen Brand, Wrestler
- Ross Flood, Wrestler
- Stanley Henson, Contributor
- Harold Nichols, Coach
- Robin Reed, Wrestler
- E. Gray Simons, Wrestler/Coach
- William Smith, Wrester/Contributor
Class of 1979
- Doug Blubaugh, Wrestler
- Dr. Albert deFerrari, Contributor
- Frank Lewis, Wrestler
- Joe McDaniel, Wrestler/Coach
- Charlie Speidel, Coach
- Keith Young, Wrestler/Contributor
Class of 1980
- Dan Gable, Wrestler
- William “Billy” Martin, Coach/Contributor
- William “Bill” Nelson, Wrestler/Contributor
- Ed Peery, Wrestler/Coach
- Hugh Peery, Wrestler
- Robert S. Siddens, Coach
- Dale Thomas, Wrestler/Coach/Contributor
- Yojiro Uetake Obata, Wrestler
Class of 1981
- David “Buddy” Arndt, Wrestler
- Conrad Caldwell, Wrestler
- Lowell Lange, Wrestler
- Robert Pearce, Wrestler
- Arnold Umbach, Coach
Class of 1982
- Wayne Baughman, Wrestler
- Finn Eriksen, Contributor
- William Kerslake, Wrestler
- George Martin, Contributor
- Wayne Wells, Wrestler
- Shelby Wilson, Wrestler
Class of 1983
- Lloyd Appleton, Wrestler
- Robert “Bob” Dellinger, Contributor
- Guy Lookabaugh, Wrestler
- Peter Mehringer, Wrestler
- Mike Milkovich, Coach
Class of 1984
- Richard Voliva, Wrestler/Coach
- Vince Zuaro, Contributor
Class of 1985
- Steve Combs, Contributor
- Gene Davis, Wrestler
- Manuel Gorriaran, Contributor
- Wallace “Wally” Johnson, Coach
Class of 1986
- Frank “Sprig” Gardner, Coach
- Ben Peterson, Wrestler
- John Peterson, Wrestler
Class of 1987
- Bobby Douglas, Wrestler
- William Farrell, Coach/Contributor
- Grady Peninger, Coach
- Richard Sanders, Wrestler
- Joe Scalzo, Contributor
Class of 1989
- Russ Hellickson, Wrestler/Coach/Contributor
Class of 1990
- Stan Abel, Wrestler/Coach
- Leroy Kemp Jr., Wrestler
- Walter O’Connell, Coach
- Ray Swartz, Coach
Class of 1991
- Richard Barker, Coach
- Michael Caruso, Wrestler
- Wade Schalles, Wrestler, Contributor
Class of 1992
- LeRoy Alitz, Coach
- Marvin Hess, Coach/Contributor
- Paul Scott, Coach
- John Vaughn, Contributor
Class of 1993
- Ed Banach, Wrestler
- Werner Holzer, Wrestler/Contributor
- Allie Morrison, Wrestler
- William “Bily” Thom, Coach
Class of 1994
- Edward Aliverti, Contributor
- Lou Banach, Wrestler
- Steve Fraser, Wrestler
- Doug Lee, Wrestler
Class of 1995
- Henry Boresch, Coach
- Tommy Chesbro, Coach
- Richard DiBatista, Wrestler
- Dick Hutton, Wrestler
- Mark Schultz, Wrestler
Class of 1996
- Stan Dziedzic, Wrestler/Coach
- Johnny Eareckson, Wrestler/Coach
- Dr. Melvin Jones, Contributor
- Lloyd Keaser, Wrestler
Class of 1997
- George Dole, Wrestler
- Ken Kraft, Coach/Contributor
- Dave Schultz, Wrestler
- John Smith, Wrestler
Class of 1998
- John Hancock, Coach
- Randy Lewis, Wrestler
- William Scherr, Wrestler
- Joe Seay, Coach
Class of 1999
- Jeff Blatnick, Wrestler
- Mark Churella, Wrestler
- Art Martori, Contributor
- John Reese, Coach
Class of 2000
- Gary Kurdelmeier, Coach
- Pat Milkovich, Wrestler
- Gene Mills, Wrestler
- James Peckham, Wrester/Coach
Class of 2001
- Kurt Angle, Wrestler
- Tom Brands, Wrestler
- Kenny Monday, Wrestler
- Alan Rice, Wrestler/Coach/Contributor
- Rick Tucci, Wrestler/Coach
Class of 2002
- Bruce Baumgartner, Wrestler
- Kendall Cross, Wrestler
- Jim Scherr, Wrestler/Contributor
Class of 2003
- Nate Carr, Wrestler/Coach
- Louis Giani, Coach
- Kevin Jackson, Wrestler
- Arthur Maughan, Wrestler/Coach/Contributor
Class of 2004
- Leslie Anderson, Wrestler/Coach
- Don Behm, Wrestler
- Larry Hayes, Wrestler
- Jim Zalesky, Wrestler/Coach
Class of 2005
- Robert Bubb, Wrestler/Coach/Competitor
- Christopher Campbell, Wrestler
- Zeke Jones, Wrestler/Coach
- J Robinson, Coach/Contributor
Class of 2006
- Terry Brands, Wrestler
- Josiah Henson, Wrestler/Contributor
- Tricia Saunders, Wrestler/Coach
- Patrick Smith, Wrestler
Class of 2007
- Barry Davis, Wrestler
- Greg Gibson, Wrestler
- Larry Kristoff, Wrestler/Coach
- William Weick, Coach
Class of 2008
- Ricky Bonomo, Wrestler
- Mike Houck, Wrestler
- Wayne Martin, Wrestler
- Robert “Bobby” Weaver, Wrestler
Class of 2009
- Peter Blair, Wrestler
- Edward Eichelberger, Wrestler
- Les Gutches, Wrestler
- Dennis Koslowski, D.C., Wrestler
Class of 2010
- Dave Auble, Wrestler/Coach
- Russell Camilleri, Wrestler
- Rulon Gardner, Wrestler
- Lincoln McIlravy, Wrestler
Class of 2011
- Daniel Brand, Wrestler
- Richard Delgado, Wrestler
- Dennis Hall, Wrestler
- Cael Sanderson, Wrestler
Class of 2012
- Fred Fozzard, Wrestler
- Stephen Neal, Wrestler
- Greg Strobel, Wrestler/Coach
- Chris Taylor, Wrestler
Class of 2013
- Dan Chandler, Wrestler/Coach/Contributor
- Melvin Douglas III, Wrestler
- Matt Ghaffari, Wrestler
- Ron Gray, Wrestler/Coach
Class of 2014
- Eric Guerrero, Wrestler/Coach
- Dean Lahr, Wrestler
- Mickey Martin, Wrestler
- Kerry McCoy, Wrestler
Class of 2015
- Frank Bettucci, Wrestler
- Joe Gonzales, Wrestler
- Sammie Henson, Wrestler
- Gregory Johnson, Wrestler
Class of 2016
- Bill Harlow, Wrestler/Coach
- Carlton Haselrig, Wrestler
- Brandon Slay, Wrestler
- Dick Wilson, Wrestler
Class of 2017
- Tony Gizoni, Wrestler
- Cary Kolat, Wrestler
- Andre Metzger, Wrestler
Class of 2018
- Stephen Abas, Wrestler
- Lee Allen, Wrestler/Coach
- Henry Cejudo, Wrestler
- Kristie Davis, Wrestler
Class of 2019
- Carl Adams, Wrestler/Coach/
- Lorenzo, Wrestler
- Brandon Paulson, Wrestler/Coach
- Townsend Saunders, Wrestler
Class of 2021
- Bruce Burnett, Coach
- Dremiel Byers, Wrestler
- Mark Lieberman, Wrestler
- Bill Zadick, Wrestler/Coach
Class of 2022
- Clarissa Chun, Wrestler
- Sara McMann, Wrestler
- Andy Rein, Wrestler/Coach
- Jake Varner, Wrestler
Class of 2023
- Rich Bender, Contributor
- Jimmy Jackson, Wrestler
- Patricia Miranda, Wrestler
- Joseph E. Williams, Wrestler
Class of 2024
- Tadaaki Hatta, Wrestler
- Toccara Montgomery, Wrestler
- Coleman Scott, Coach
- Logan Stieber, Wrestler