Class of 2001
- Bill Mazeroski, Second Baseman, Pittsburgh Pirates
- Kirby Puckett, Center Fielder, Minnesota Twins
- Hilton Smith, Pitcher, Kansas City Monarchs
- Dave Winfield, Right Fielders, New York Yankees
Class of 2002
- Ozzie Smith, Shortstop, St. Louis Cardinals
Class of 2003
- Gary Carter, Catcher, Montreal Expos
- Eddie Murray, First Baseman, Baltimore Orioles
Class of 2004
- Dennis Eckersley, Pitcher, Oakland A’s
- Paul Monitor, Designated Hitter, Milwaukee Brewers
Class of 2005
- Wade Boggs, Third Baseman, Boston Red Sox
- Ryne Sandberg, Second Baseman, Chicago Cubs
Class of 2006
- Ray Brown, Pitcher, Homestead Grays
- Willard Brown, Center Fielder, Kansas City Monarchs
- Andy Cooper, Pitcher
- Frank Grant, Second Baseman
- Pete Hill, Center Fielder
- Biz Mackey, Catcher
- Effa Manley, Executive/Pioneer
- Jose Mendez, Pitcher, Cuban stars
- Alex Pompez, Executive/Pioneer
- Cum Posey, Executive/Pioneer, Homestead Grays
- Louis Santop, Catcher
- Bruce Sutter, Pitcher, Chicago Cubs
- Mule Suttles, First Baseman, Newark Eagles
- Ben Taylor, First Baseman
- Cristobal Torriente, Center Fielder
- Sol White, Executive/Pioneer
- J.L. Wilkinson, Executive/Pioneer, Kansas City Monarchs
- Jud Wilson, Third Baseman, Kansas City Monarchs
Class of 2007
- Tony Gwynn, Right Fielder, San Diego Padres
- Cal Ripken, Shortstop, Baltimore Orioles
Class of 2008
- Barney Dreyfuss, Executive/Pioneer
- Rich Gossage, Pitcher, New York Yankees
- Bowie Kuhn, Executive/Pioneer
- Walter O’Malley, Executive/Pioneer
- Billy Southworth, Manager, St. Louis Cardinals
- Dick Williams, Manager, Montreal Expos
Class of 2009
- Joe Gordon, Second Baseman, New York Yankees
- Rickey Henderson, Left Fielder, Oakland A’s
- Jim Rice, Left Fielder, Boston Red Sox
Class of 2010
- Andre Dawson, Center Fielder, Montreal Expos
- Doug Harvey, Umpire
- Whitey Herzog, Manager, St. Louis Cardinals
Class of 2011
- Roberto Alomar, 2nd Baseman, Toronto Blue Jays
- Bert Blyleven, Pitcher, Minnesota Twins
- Pat Gillick, Executive, Toronto Blue Jays
Class of 2012
- Barry Larkin, Shortstop, Cincinnati Reds
- Ron Santo, 3rd Baseman, Chicago Cubs
Class of 2013
- Hank O’Day, Umpire
- Jacob Ruppert, Executive, New York Yankees
- Deacon White, 3rd Baseman, Buffalo Bisons
Class of 2014
- Bobby Cox, Manager, Atlanta Braves
- Tom Glavine, Pitcher, Atlanta Braves
- Tony La Russa, Manager, No Primary Team Selected
- Greg Maddux, Pitcher, Atlanta Braves
- Frank Thomas, 1st Baseman, Chicago White Sox
- Joe Torre, Manager, New York Yankees
Class of 2015
- Craig Biggio, 2nd Baseman, Houston Astros
- Randy Johnson, Pitcher, Seattle Mariners
- Pedro Martinez, Pitcher, Boston Red Sox
- John Smoltz, Pitcher, Atlanta Braves
Class of 2016
- Ken Griffey Jr., Center Fielder, Seattle Mariners
- Mike Piazza, Catcher, New York Mets
Class of 2017
- Jeff Bagwell, 1st Baseman, Houston Astros
- Tim Raines Sr., Left Fielder, Montreal Expos
- Iván Rodríguez, Catcher, Texas Rangers
- John Schuerholz, Executive, Kansas City Royals, Atlanta Braves
- Bud Selig, Executive, Major League Baseball
Class of 2018
- Vladimir Guerrero, Right Fielder, Montreal Expos
- Trevor Hoffman, Pitcher, San Diego Padres
- Chipper Jones, 3rd Baseman, Atlanta Braves
- Jack Morris, Pitcher, Detroit Tigers
- Jim Thome, 1st Baseman, Cleveland Indians
- Alan Trammell, Shortstop, Detroit Tigers
Class of 2019
- Harold Baines, Designated Hitter, Chicago White Sox
- Roy Hallady, Pitcher, Toronto Blue Jays
- Edgar Martinez, Designated Hitter, Seattle Mariners
- Mike Mussina, Pitcher, Baltimore Orioles AL
- Mariano Rivera, Pitcher, New York Yankees
- Lee Smith, Pitcher, Chicago Cubs
Class of 2020
- Derek Jeter, Shortstop, New York Yankees
- Marvin Miller, Executive, Major League Baseball Players Association
- Ted Simmons, Catcher, St. Louis Cardinals
- Larry Walker, Right Fielder, Colorado Rockies
Class of 2021
- No inductees
Class of 2022
- Bud Fowler, Executive, Legend
- Gil Hodges, 1st Baseman, Brooklyn Dodgers
- Jim Kaat, Pitcher, Minnesota Twins
- Minnie Miñoso, Left Fielder, Chicago White Sox
- Buck O’Neil, Executive, Kansas City Monarchs
- Tony Oliva, Right Fielder, Minnesota Twins
- David Ortiz, Designated Hitter, Boston Red Sox
Class of 2023
- Fred McGriff, 1st Baseman, No Primary Team Selected
- Scott Rolen, 3rd Baseman, Philadelphia Phillies
Class of 2024
- Adrián Beltré, 3rd Baseman, Texas Rangers
- Todd Helton, 1st Baseman, Colorado Rockies
- Joe Mauer, Catcher, Minnesota Twins
- Jim Leyland, Manager, Team, No Primary Team Selected