New York Mets as Primary Team
- Mike Piazza, Catcher, 1998-2005, Class of 2016
- Tom Seaver, Pitcher, 1967-1977, 1983, Class of 1992
Hall of Famers who also played for the New York Mets
- Roberto Alomar, 2nd Baseman, 2002-2003, Class of 2011
- Richie Ashburn, Center Fielder, 1962, Class of 1995
- Yogi Berra, Catcher, 1965, Class of 1972
- Gary Carter, Catcher, 1985-1989, Class of 2003
- Tom Glavine, Pitcher, 2003-2007, Class of 2014
- Rickey Henderson, Left Fielder, 1999-2000, Class of 2009
- Gil Hodges, 1st Baseman, 1962-1963, Class of 2022
- Pedro Martinez, Pitcher, 2005-2008, Class of 2015
- Willie Mays, Center Fielder, 1972-1973, Class of 1979
- Eddie Murray, 1st Baseman, 1992-1993, Class of 2003
- Nolan Ryan, Pitcher, 1966, 1968-1971, Class of 1999
- Warren Spahn, Pitcher, 1965, Class of 1973
Carolina Panthers in the Hall of Fame
Reggie White, Defensive End, 2000, Class of 2006