Class of 1990
- Cecil Smith
- Thomas Hitchcock, Jr.
- Stewart B. Iglehart
- Harry Payne Whitney
- Devereaux Milburn
- Robert Skene
Class of 1991
- Eric Pedley
- Winston F. C. Guest
- J. Watson Webb
- George K. Oliver
Class of 1992
- Louis E. Stoddard
- Carlton Beal
- James Gordon Bennett
- Foxhall P. Keene
- Dr. Clarence C. “Buddy” Combs Jr.
- Alan L. Corey, Jr.
Class of 1993
- Philip L. B. Inglehart
- James “Monty” Waterbury
- Lawrence Waterbury
- W. Ray Harrington Jr.
Class of 1994
- John T. Osley
- Michael G. Phipps
- Northrup R. Knox
- William R. Linfoot
Class of 1995
- Louise Eustis Hitchcock
- Roy M. Barry
- William A. Mayer
- Paul Butler
Class of 1996
- Robert E. Strawbridge Jr.
- Stephen J. Roberts
- George H. Bostwick
- William T. Ylvisaker
Class of 1997
- Fred W. Dailey
- Lewis A. Smith
- Stephen M. Gose
- Guillermo “Memo” Gracida, Jr.
Class of 1998
- Malcolm Stevenson
- Tommy Wayman
- Norman Brinker
- George C. Sherman Jr.
Class of 1999
- Lester (Red) Armour, III
- Harold A. (Joe) Barry
- Al Parsells
- Elmer Boeseke
Class of 2000
- W. L. (Willis) Hartman
- H. L. (Henry Lloyd) Herbert
- Robert E. (Rob) Walton
Class of 2001
- Bart Evans
- S. K. (Skey) Johnston, Jr.
- Robert (Bob) Uihlein
Class of 2002
- Thomas Hitchcock Sr.
- Glen Holden Sr.
- George Haas Jr.
Class of 2003
- Bennie Gutierrez
- Delman Carroll
Class of 2004
- Rodolphe Agassiz
- Charles Smith
Class of 2005
- John C. “Jack” Oxley
- Will Rogers
Class of 2006
- Paul W. “Bill” Barry
- Raymond Guest
- Robert D. Beveridge
Class of 2007
- John E. Cowdin
- William Sinclaire
Class of 2008
- Gonzalo Pieres
- W. Averell Harriman
Class of 2009
- Gonzalo Tanoira
- Owen Rinehart
Class of 2010
- Julian Hipwood
- Lewis Lacey
Class of 2011
- Stephen A. Orthwein
- Charles Cary Rumsey
Class of 2012
- Carlos Gracida
- James P. “Jimmy” Mills
Class of 2013
- Michael Azzaro
- Robert Gould Shaw, II
Class of 2014
- Adam Snow
- Peter Perkins
Class of 2015
- Stephen “Laddie” Sanford
- Juan Carlos Harriott, Jr.
Class of 2016
- Hector Galindo
- Billy Post
Class of 2017
- Mariano Aguerre
- John “Jackie” Murphy
Class of 2018
- Sunset “Sunny” Hale
- Ruben Gracida
Class of 2019
- Daniel Gonzalez
- Gerlad Matthews Balding
Class of 2020
- Cyril Harrison
- Joey Casey
Class of 2021
- Julio Arellano
- John J. “Jack” Ivory
Class of 2022
- Cornelius Vanderbilt Whitney
- Thomas J. Biddle Jr.
Class of 2023
- Jeffrey Stuart Hall
- Aidan Roark