Team also known as
- Cincinnati Redlegs 1954-1958
- Cincinnati Reds 1890-1953
- Cincinnati Red Stockings 1882-1889
Cincinnati Reds as Primary Team
- Johnny Bench, Catcher, 1967-1983, Class of 1989
- George Kelly, 1st Baseman, 1927-1930, Class of 1973
- Barry Larkin, Shortstop, 1986-2004, Class of 2012
- Ernie Lombardi, Catcher, 1932-1941, Class of 1986
- Bill McKechnie, Manager, 1938-1946, Class of 1962
- Bid McPhee (Cincinnati Red Stockings), 1882-1889, 2nd Baseman, Class of 2000
- Joe Morgan, 2nd Baseman, 1972-1979, Class of 1990
- Tony Pérez, 1st Baseman, 1964-1976, Class of 2000
- Eppa Rixey, Pitcher, 1921-1933, Class of 1963
- Frank Robinson, Right Fielder, 1956-1965, Class of 1982
- Edd Roush, Center Fielder, 1916-1926, 1931, Class of 1962
- Tom Seaver, Pitcher, 1977-1982, Class of 1992
Hall of Famers who also played for the Cincinnati Reds
- Sparky Anderson, Manager, 1970-1978, Class of 2000
- Jake Beckley, 1st Baseman, 1897-1903, Class of 1971
- Jim Bottomley, 1st Baseman, 1933-1935, Class of 1974
- Mordecai Brown, Pitcher, 1913, Class of 1949
- Sam Crawford, Right Fielder, 1899-1902, Class of 1957
- Kiki Cuyler, Right Fielder, 1935-1937, Class of 1968
- William “Buck” Ewin, Catcher, 1895-1897, Class of 1939
- Ken Griffey, Jr, Center Fielder, 2000-2008, Class of 2016
- Chick Hafey, Outfielder, 1932-1935, 1937, Class of 1971
- Jesse Haines, Pitcher, 1918, Class of 1970
- Harry Heilmann, Right Fielder, 1930, 1932, Class of 1952
- Rube Marquard, Pitcher, 1921, Class of 1971
- Christy Mathewson, Pitcher, 1916, Class of 1936
- Amos Rusie, Pitcher, 1901, Class of 1977
- Al Simmons, Left Fielder, 1939, Class of 1953
- Lee Smith, Pitcher, 1996, Class of 2019
- Joe Tinker, Shortstop, 1913, Class of 1946
- Lloyd Waner, Center Fielder, 1941, Class of 1967
Carolina Panthers in the Hall of Fame
Reggie White, Defensive End, 2000, Class of 2006